Home Buy Rent Sell About Contact


Good Neighbor Realty was started over 30 years ago by Paul & Polly Bollinger. Paul & Polly moved to Wagoner in the 1970’s and began development of Bollinger Addition. Shortly thereafter they purchased a building located at 226 W. Cherokee in Wagoner,Oklahoma and Good Neighbor Realty began.

During their lifetime, they purchased over 80 homes for the purpose of renting and established a reputation of conducting their Real Estate business with honesty and integrity. Polly passed away in 1999, followed by Paul in 2000. The business is now owned by their two daughters, Lynda Cantrell and Debi Hamilton. Debi oversees and runs the day to day business with the help of a great office staff and maintenance crew for the rentals, which now includes over 110 homes.

In 2005, Good Neighbor Realty, remodeled and expanded our office space to accommodate our growing needs. In 2007, we joined the Muskogee Association of Realtors to provide the greatest level of service to our Muskogee & Ft. Gibson customers. By being members of both the Greater Tulsa Association of Realtors and the Muskogee Association of Realtors, we feel we have an added advantage for our customers by giving our buyers greater area searching coverage and giving our sellers greater advertising coverage.

It has always been our goal to continue what Paul and Polly started by putting the customer first and working for you, not the deal.